PRETORIA – The proposed appointment of KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Police Commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi as national head of the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (DPCI), commonly known as the Hawks, has drawn criticism from analyst Dr Isaac Mashaba, who believes the move could be politically motivated. The proposal follows the retirement of former Hawks head Lieutenant-General Godfrey Lebeya in May 2025, since when Lieutenant-General Siphesihle Nkosi has served in an acting capacity. The Ministry of Police has presented the proposed appointment as part of its Police Reset Agenda, but Mashaba believes that moving Mkhwanazi out of KwaZulu-Natal could undermine policing efforts in the province.
Mashaba questions the need for a transfer
Mashaba argued that Mkhwanazi should remain in KwaZulu-Natal to continue his work as provincial police commissioner. “There is no war in KZN that Mkhwanazi cannot handle or stabilise,” he said. “The general has stabilised that province, the nation is happy with where Mkhwanazi is, and he should be given the freedom to continue doing his work there.” He warned that a national position in Pretoria would take Mkhwanazi away from direct provincial policing responsibilities, and expressed concern about the potential impact on efforts to combat organised crime in the province.
Political motives questioned
Mashaba also questioned the reasons behind the proposed appointment, suggesting that it may be driven by political considerations rather than a genuine need to strengthen the Hawks. “The Minister is trying to be silly by appointing Mkhwanazi as the head of the Hawks,” he said, describing the proposal as an attempt to neutralise a commander who, in his view, is unwilling to compromise. “This is a political strategy. The Minister and political actors are trying to protect themselves from an uncompromised commander,” Mashaba alleged. He predicted that political parties would challenge the proposal: “Political parties will be making serious noise about this because they are not happy. They see this for what it is – a move to neutralise him.”
Concerns over the Hawks’ independence
Mashaba drew comparisons between the Hawks and the former Directorate of Special Operations, commonly known as the Scorpions, which was disbanded in 2009. He argued that the Scorpions’ history shows how vulnerable specialised crime-fighting institutions are to political and legislative change. “We must remember that under former President Jacob Zuma’s leadership, the Scorpions were disbanded,” he said. “The Hawks can be disbanded at any time, just like the Scorpions were.” He cautioned that placing Mkhwanazi at the head of the Hawks could expose him to political interference and to institutional changes that might affect the unit’s work.
Mashaba favours national police commissioner role
Mashaba maintained that if the intention is to give Mkhwanazi a national leadership role, he should be considered for National Commissioner of the South African Police Service (SAPS) rather than head of the Hawks. “If he is to be appointed anywhere at a national level, the position Mkhwanazi should be appointed to is National Police Commissioner, not the Hawks head,” he said. He concluded by stressing the importance of independent policing and repeating his view that Mkhwanazi should stay in KwaZulu-Natal. “SAPS must remain independent. The nation is completely satisfied with Mkhwanazi serving the people where he is, and it is best to keep him there,” he said.








